The problem with hot water heaters are the lack of safety’s. The only real safety is the T&P valve the other is an operating controller..
The boiler on the other hand according to the ASME section IV and the Nattional Board of boiler inspectors must have both operating and safety controllers
The problem could be a partically blocked flue pipe (chiminey) that the water heater would never pick up BUT the spill switch on the boiler would shut down on safety.
You should have this checked out by a licensed master plumber/ gas fitter to make sure your not getting CO coming back into your home. Incomplete combustion is a very dangerious condition that could quite easily lead to death.
If you go to the top of this page to “plumbviews” and go to Authors you will find several articles I have written about this very problem GOOD LUCK. SylvanLMP
SylvanLMP
[Edited by SylvanLMP on 23 March 2000]